sailors+outcome

Defining Law Notes Previous Page



This case is interesting because it brings up a number of questions. It made the jurors in the actual case consider the role of morals in the law. It also brings up a number of questions for us to consider in class. Answer the following questions concerning the case.

Name __ 1. Should Dudley and Stephens be tried for murder?

2. As an attorney for Dudley and Stephens, what arguments would you make on their behalf?

3. As an attorney for the state, what arguments would you make?

4. If they are convicted, what should their punishment be?

5. What purpose would be served by convicting them?

6. What is the relationship between the law and morality in this case?

7. Was it morally wrong for Dudley and Stephens to kill Brooks? Explain.

8. Can an act be legal but immoral? Explain.

9. Can an act be morally right but illegal? Explain.